Is it more of a blessing or a curse to have the ability to
alter our genetic codes?
Do the deafs have as much right as the rest of
us to abort a fetus that is, in their view, disabled?
Is
"disability" a relative term?
What constitute to a person's
disability?
Is it in Heather's best interest to be raised as the only hearing
child in the family?
Personally I think that deaf people do not have the right to
abort a fetus that seems to be disabled to them. The term of disabled may be
referred to people who have been deprived of a capability resulted in being
isolated from the society. If the fetus is a hearing child, it does not make
the child disabled because if the child learns sign language, he or she could
not be isolated from the deaf society. The child could also interact normally
with the normal society with hearing people, which shows no signs of disability
in either society. Therefore, I don’t think deaf people have the right to abort
a ‘disabled child’. They could raise the child their way and teach the child
sign languages and deaf culture but not to abort the child just because the
child is not perfectly like them.
Speaking of disability, one of the questions associates with
it is that is deaf a blessing or curse? Not everyone gets to experience such
different forms of life but being different from others, not able to hear
anything and being treated as disability could this be blessing? The deaf society
in the video obviously feels proud to be deaf and is proud of their culture. However,
at the same time, the society is isolated from normal hearing society, causing
them to stay isolated. Personally I think that it is up to the person to decide
whether deaf is a blessing or a curse but for me, I would not want to be deaf.
Not for my whole life. It would become really hard for me if I ever have to go
through my day without listening music, talking to people and hearing to the
sound of nature every morning.
An example of a ‘disabled child’ in a family would be Heather.
Heather wanting to be the only hearing child in the family has caused a lot of arguments
and family separation but she finally got the cochlear implant. The family had
been through a long discussion on whether Heather should receive the implant or
not. They think the surgery is dangerous and that if Heather has gotten the
implant, she would forget or abandon the deaf culture. The original decision of
not getting the implant was also made when Heather was only five years old.
However, the parents had changed their thoughts and gotten Heather the implant
when she turned 15. I personally think that it is of best interest for Heather
to receive the cochlear implant because being able to hear is a precious
experience for deaf people. Besides, by taking off the device, Heather becomes
deaf again and could fit into the deaf society once more. There is no lost for
Heather to receive the implant. It is brings such great changes to the family,
allowing them to normally interact with hearing people while still understand
and experience deaf culture.